Posts Tagged ‘Engadget’

Social Media Blog: Engadget Comments Back on

Friday, February 5th, 2010

Engadget's blog is now allowing comments again, only two days after Editor-in-chief, Joshua Topolsky, announced that things had gotten out of hand and they were going to stop commenting until things settled down.
 
Well, it appears that things have settled down fairly quickly. Or rather Engadget has found a solution to their problem of getting a lot of "ugly, threatening, and spam" comments.

Topolsky announced on Thursday (Feb 4th) that they have made changes to keep "comments clean and comfortable for everyone who wants to join in the discussion — not just the loudest of the bunch."

Basically, readers of Engadget will now have the option of switching off the comments functionality and Engadget has deployed tools to allow their editors to moderate the comments more "effectively and efficienty".

They've also outlined a lot of ground rules for users. They want comments to be "reasonably polite" and lighthearted where possible. Of course anyone taking personal potshots at others including their editors will not be allowed and that they would delete any comments that were racist, sexist, or obscene.

Hmmm…but even if they allowed "unfiltered" comments, shouldn't Engadget have been doing some of that already? They could have implemented some automated monitoring to delete racial or obscene comments even if they didn't have a team of people monitoring comments.

But anyway, a blog is again a blog on Engadget. So have it and go comment on their site. Be sure to be "lighthearted" too when commenting on their site or Joshua Topolsky may get mad…..

Social Media Blog: Engadget Turns off Comments

Tuesday, February 2nd, 2010

What's blogging without comments? A blog means two-way dialog; one person posts, several comment, right?
 
Well, Engadget, a technology blog has stopped allowing comments on their blog because they felt that the tone of the comments had "really gotten out of hand."

Engadget editor-in-chief Joshua Topolsky said in an announcement that "We know you like to have your fun, voice your opinions, and argue over your favorite gear, but over the past few days the tone in comments has really gotten out of hand,…."
 
Topolsky went on to say that what is supposed to a fun environment for their users and editors had become mean, ugly, and in some situations, threatening which was "just not acceptable".
 
And it ended with something to the effect of "everyone cool down" and that Engadget will allow comments on their blog again when they feel that things have settled down some.
 
Websites which allow unfiltered comments from users is a very common problem faced by many sites including most of the newspaper and television blog sites.
 
This "unfiltered" commentary is a growing concern for most of us who like to play in the online networks. Should all comments be monitored? Should websites which serve as an informational source be setting up a whole "comment management" team?

More to come……….